Welcome to Clip from Spiral logo

Interactive video lesson plan for: The Division - Problematic Meaning in Mechanics - Extra Credits

Activity overview:

Tom Clancy's The Division uses the present day United States as a setting, but it runs roughshod over the real and troubling issues facing American society. It glorifies totalitarianism and the use of force against citizens whose rights are ignored and whose humanity is stripped away by mechanics that directly equate racial and class stereotypes with villainhood. (---More below)

Subscribe for new episodes every Wednesday!
Get your Extra Credits gear at the store!
Play games with us on Extra Play!

Watch more episodes from this season of Extra Credits!

Talk to us on Twitter (@ExtraCreditz):
Follow us on Facebook:
Get our list of recommended games on Steam:

Police violence, vigilantism, and struggle between security and liberty are core issues facing America today, and Tom Clancy's The Division addresses all of them - but it does so in a callous and unthinking way. The game takes place in the real world, with no war to throw a pall of justification over its violence, nor convenient alien or zombie enemies to direct it towards. Instead, the villains are US citizens who have survived a bioterrorist attack and who are now accused of disrupting the government's attempts to restore order in an epidemic wasted city. The player is a newly activated member of a secret military organization which answers only to the President, and is instructed to kill these so-called thugs. This is the definition of totalitarianism, and it plays out like a game about being an SS agent under the Nazi regime. It encourages and glorifies the same type of violence associated with recent police shootings that have divided the nation, and the thoughtless way it does that disgraces both law enforcement officials and people who've died in these shootings. It also uses hoodies to distinguish an entire enemy faction: people to be shot on sight. Given that the hoodie worn by Trayvon Martin has become a symbol used to demonize people of color, one which protestors have tried to take back by wearing it in solidarity with victims, this lazy stereotype on game's part is appalingly callous. It dehumanizes these enemies by having NPCs yell pejoratives at them, and what hints it does give as to their real lives and backgrounds outside of being targets consistently reinforce class lines by showing them as working class or poor people. The Division does feature a strong and diverse cast of NPCs, but their presence only underlines how tone deaf the main story is: diversity means more than including people of color. It also means being conscious and considerate of the real issues faced in our shared culture today. To explain its decisions, the game claims inspiration from Operation: Dark Winter, a study conducted in 2001 under the Bush administration which met with heavy criticism and is now fifteen years out of date. But even those findings seem out of touch when we've seen multiple epidemics (like SARS or ebola) pass by without causing a complete breakdown on the scale that the Division suggests might happen. Regardless of intent, the game ultimately embraces totalitarianism, government brutality, stereotyping, fearmongering, and classism without applying enough thought to make a coherent message out of these volatile themes in its mechanics.

Would you like James to speak at your school or organization? For info, contact us at: soraya[at]extra-credits[dot]net

♫ Get the intro music here!

♫ Get the outro music here!

Tagged under: mechanics,extra credits (award-nominated work),james portnow,daniel floyd,division,game narrative,game design,video game,extra credits,game development,Tom Clancy,Tom Clancy' The Division,Tom Clancy' Division,Clancy game,Tom Clancy game,Clancy,Division,PATRIOT Act,Directive 51,Dark Winter,Operation Dark Winter,Bush administration,government,law enforcement,hoodie,thug,liberty security,meaning,analysis,propaganda,totalitarian,totalitarianism,vigilante

Clip makes it super easy to turn any public video into a formative assessment activity in your classroom.

Add multiple choice quizzes, questions and browse hundreds of approved, video lesson ideas for Clip

Make YouTube one of your teaching aids - Works perfectly with lesson micro-teaching plans

Play this activity

1. Students enter a simple code

2. You play the video

3. The students comment

4. You review and reflect

* Whiteboard required for teacher-paced activities

Share on:

Share The Division - Problematic Meaning in Mechanics - Extra Credits on Google+ Share The Division - Problematic Meaning in Mechanics - Extra Credits on Twitter Share The Division - Problematic Meaning in Mechanics - Extra Credits on Facebook Pin The Division - Problematic Meaning in Mechanics - Extra Credits Email The Division - Problematic Meaning in Mechanics - Extra Credits

Ready to see what else Spiral logo can do?

With four apps, each designed around existing classroom activities, Spiral gives you the power to do formative assessment with anything you teach.


Carry out a quickfire formative assessment to see what the whole class is thinking


Create interactive presentations to spark creativity in class

Team Up

Student teams can create and share collaborative presentations from linked devices


Turn any public video into a live chat with questions and quizzes

1000s of teachers use Spiral to deliver awesome, engaging activities that capture students' understanding during lessons.

Now it's your turn Sign up

Spiral Reviews by Teachers and Digital Learning Coaches

Review of Spiral by teacher: Kathryn Laster @kklaster

Tried out the canvas response option on @SpiralEducation & it's so awesome! Add text or drawings AND annotate an image! #R10tech

Review of Spiral by teacher: Room 220 Math Stars @3rdgradeBCE

Using @SpiralEducation in class for math review. Student approved! Thumbs up! Thanks.

Review of Spiral by teacher: Miss Ord @ordmiss

Absolutely amazing collaboration from year 10 today. 100% engagement and constant smiles from all #lovetsla #spiral

Review of Spiral by teacher: Adam J. Stryker @strykerstennis

Students show better Interpersonal Writing skills than Speaking via @SpiralEducation Great #data #langchat folks!

Review of Spiral by teacher: Dr Ayla Göl @iladylayla

A good tool for supporting active #learning.

Review of Spiral by teacher: Brett Erenberg @BrettErenberg

The Team Up app is unlike anything I have ever seen. You left NOTHING out! So impressed!

Get the Clip Chrome Extension & Create Video Lessons in Seconds

Add Clip to Chrome